The W. Ward Reynoldson award is presented to the coaches whose teams made AMTA’s national final round.
| 1985 | Peter Leigh, Eastern Illinois University Don Racheter, Central College of Iowa |
| 1986 | James Walker and Kanti Kotecha, Wright State University Helen Palmer, Storrs Downey, Northwestern University |
| 1987 | Steve Hatting and Logan Langwith, College of St. Thomas Ruth and Jim Wagoner, Bellarmine College |
| 1988 | John McKiernan and Dean Spader, University of South Dakota Jim Walker, Wright State University |
| 1989 | Patty Notch, Nan Horvat, and Rob Tully, Drake University Steve Hatting and Logan Langwith, College of St. Thomas |
| 1990 | Marcus Pohlmann and Whit Gurkin, Rhodes College Dennis Lyle and Peter Handwork, Toledo Community College |
| 1991 | Marcus Pohlmann and Whit Gurkin, Rhodes College Ruth and Jim Wagoner, Bellarmine College |
| 1992 | Noel Myricks, University of Maryland |
| 1993 | Alan Olson and Patty Notch, Drake University Tim Cole and Bill Thrush, University of Maryland |
| 1994 | Marcus Pohlmann and Whit Gurkin, Rhodes College Ruth and Jim Wagoner, Bellarmine College |
| 1995 | Marcus Pohlmann and Whit Gurkin, Rhodes College Mary Lynn Neuhaus, Edward Skaggs III, and Charles Jacobs, Loras College |
| 1996 | Mary Pat Wilt and George Failla, Jr., University of Maryland Charles Fleener and Bradley Dede, Saint Louis University |
| 1997 | Debyii Sababu Thomas and Felecia Walker, Howard University Marcus Pohlmann and Marty McAfee, Rhodes College |
| 1998 | Scott Hinshaw, Cathy Henger, and George Failla, Jr., University of Maryland Ruth Wagoner, Jim Wagoner, and Jason Cooper, Bellarmine College |
| 1999 | Ruth Wagoner, Jim Wagoner, and Jason Cooper, Bellarmine College Marcus Pohlmann and Marty McAfee, Rhodes College |
| 2000 | Noel Myricks, George Failla, Jr., Tim Cole, and Lilian Brown, University of Maryland Bradley Bloch, University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee |
| 2001 | Dan Herron, Miami University Marcus Pohlmann, Rhodes College |
| 2002 | Timothy Hagle, Kristofer Lyons, and Beau Brindley, University of Iowa Anthony Arend, Georgetown University |
| 2003 | Kristofer Lyons, Ryan Seelau, and Beau Brindley, University of Iowa Debyii Sababu Thomas, Felicia Walker, and Torrance Colvin, Howard University |
| 2004 | Gonzalo Freixes, University of California, Los Angeles Rebecca Selvenis and David Cross, Columbia University |
| 2005 | Gonzalo Freixes, University of California, Los Angeles Kate Wasch, Georgia Institute of Technology |
| 2006 | David Klein, David Cross, and Ryan Faulconer, University of Virginia Jerry Facher, Harvard University |
| 2007 | Toby Heytens and Ryan Faulconer, University of Virginia Cindy Skach and Jerry Facher, Harvard University |
| 2008 | Amir Sadeghy, Aisha Henry, George Failla, Jr., and Mark Graber, University of Maryland Andrew Blackwell and Jacob Chervinsky, George Washington University |
| 2009 | DeLois Leapheart, Northwood University Andrew Blackwell and Jacob Chervinsky, George Washington University |
| 2010 | Justin Matarrese, Vikram Kumar, and Justin Bernstein, New York University Jerome Facher, Harvard University |
| 2011 | Gonzalo Freixes, University of California, Los Angeles Justin Matarrese, David John Hommel, and Vikram Kumar, New York University |
| 2012 | Alex Bluebond, Kyle Thomason, and Chris Suedekum, Duke University Craig Aronow, Kimberly Yonta Aronow, and Michael Roberts, Rutgers University |
| 2013 | Neil Skene and Steve Hurm, Florida State University Marcus Pohlmann and Anna Smith, Rhodes College |
| 2014 | Gonzalo Freixes, Michael Kelly, Antoine Williams, UCLA Robert Marshall, Princeton University |
| 2015 | Christopher Ballesteros, Sean Ouellette, Joseph Resnek, Kristina Tester, and Graham Wyatt, Harvard University Yale University elected to not designate any award recipients. |
| 2016 | Yale University elected to not designate any award recipients. The Coaches of the University of Virginia |
| 2017 | The Coaches of the University of Virginia Tim Bays, Allison Durkin, Jeffrey Guo, and Raymond Zhu, Yale University |
| 2018 | Neal Schuett, Jamie Glinka, Gus Lazares, Matthew Rich, Ben Sandlin, Emily Arnzen, Alex Block, and Lawrence Hilton, Miami University Elizabeth Bays and Sam Gross, Yale University |
| 2019 | Anna Eldridge, Matthew Jehl, Zachary Kaufman Monroe, Marcus D. Pohlmann, and Meredith Rose Clement, Rhodes College |
| 2021 | Benjamin Garmoe, Dylan Rogers Elliott, Summer Akhtar, Whitney Wilder, University of Maryland, Baltimore County Alvin Winston, Yale University |
| 2022 | Sam Jahangir, Jerome Gwozdz, Caroline Veniero, University of Chicago Harvard University Friends and Family |
| 2023 | Elizabeth Smiley (Head Coach), Iain Lampert, Jonathan Freshman, Cody Smith, & Brandon Benjamin, UCLA Bennett Demsky and Alums of Harvard Mock Trial |
| 2024 | The Coaches of the University of Virginia Jonathan Church and Lindsey Church, Hillsdale College |
| 2025 | Sam Jahangir, Max Fritsch, Sam Farnsworth, Gordy Gwilt, Max Bearinger, & Jonathan Hendry, University of Chicago Neal Schuett, Ben Sandlin, Toni Bernardi, Jaime Lehmenkuler, & Emily Ullrich, Miami University |