AMTA honors members of its community with a variety of awards.
- Coaches Hall of Fame: The sole criterion for induction into the Coaches Hall of Fame is competitive success attained in an ethical and collegial manner.
- Neal Smith: Presented to one individual annually in recognition of their “contributions to AMTA’s educational mission” in a broader sense.
- W. Ward Reynoldson: Presented to the coaches whose teams made AMTA’s national final round.